Defining the "Best Interest of the Estate" in Florida Probate

Probate Lawyers in Lakeland Florida. We Provide experienced Probate Legal Services in Polk County, Central Florida and the entire State of Florida.

Call 863.250.2990 today to schedule a Free Consultation with our skilled Probate attorneys.

‹ All Posts

July 11, 2023

In Florida, as with many jurisdictions, the process of probate can often be a complex and lengthy process. A critical consideration during this process is what's considered to be in the "best interest of the estate." But what does this term really mean, and how does it apply to the Florida probate process?

In simple terms, the "best interest of the estate" refers to actions that preserve the value of the decedent's assets, pay off valid debts and expenses in a timely manner, and distribute the remaining assets to the beneficiaries according to the decedent's wishes or state law. This involves making decisions that maximize the estate's value and protect the rights of all interested parties, including the creditors and the heirs or beneficiaries.

A fundamental element of ensuring the best interest of the estate is recognizing and rejecting frivolous claims. Under Florida law, a personal representative has the responsibility to discern between valid and invalid claims against the estate. This responsibility involves a thorough review and analysis of each claim and taking appropriate steps to dispute and dismiss any claims that are frivolous or not legally enforceable.

Additionally, a crucial part of safeguarding the estate's best interests is the proper management of the estate's assets. This includes maintaining property, wisely investing funds, and avoiding unnecessary expenses or risky financial decisions that could devalue the estate.

According to Florida Statute 733.602, the personal representative, who is often named in the will or appointed by the court, has a fiduciary duty to the estate. This means they must act in the utmost good faith, with the degree of diligence, care, and skill that an ordinarily prudent person would exercise under similar circumstances.

The personal representative is also responsible for accurately inventorying the decedent's assets and determining their fair market value. This process provides a clear and precise picture of the estate's worth, which is crucial for paying off debts and properly distributing the remaining assets.

Moreover, the personal representative must ensure that the decedent's taxes are properly addressed. This may involve filing the decedent's final income tax return, paying any outstanding taxes, and potentially preparing and filing an estate tax return. The personal representative must handle these tax-related duties promptly and correctly to avoid penalties that could decrease the estate's value.

The "best interest of the estate" also extends to the distribution of assets. The personal representative must follow the instructions in the will or, if there's no will, follow Florida's laws of intestate succession. They must ensure that each beneficiary receives what they're entitled to and that the distribution process is transparent and fair.

Dealing with creditors is another critical aspect of protecting the estate's best interest. The personal representative must notify creditors of the probate proceeding, evaluate their claims, and pay off valid debts using the estate's assets. They must also be vigilant in identifying and disputing any invalid or fraudulent claims.

Beyond these responsibilities, the personal representative should keep the beneficiaries informed about the probate process. Transparency can prevent disputes and misunderstandings that could lead to legal battles, which could delay the probate process and deplete the estate's resources.

If there are disputes among the beneficiaries, the personal representative should seek to mediate these disagreements in a way that serves the best interest of the estate. In some cases, this may involve seeking the court's guidance or working with a probate attorney or mediator. In some cases, it may be in the best interest of the estate to imitate a lawsuit against a party to procure, maintain and advance the assets of the estate.

Overall, it's essential for the personal representative to act impartially, make prudent decisions, and place the estate's best interests above their own. Any mismanagement or breach of fiduciary duty can lead to legal consequences and personal liability. A personal representative of an estate is required by law to pursue assets and claims of the estate, with value.  Bookman v. Davidson, 136 So.3d 1276 (Fla. 1st DCA 2014).

As mentioned above it is essential for the personal representative to act impartially and they act in the best interest of the estate meeting their fiduciary responsibility, the court cannot require a personal representative of estate to demonstrate a monetary benefit to estate before allowing the expenditure of estate funds for the prosecution of an appeal in a wrongful death action against estate; benefit to estate was the presentation of a good faith appeal, and executor could be held accountable if appeal were subsequently determined to have been frivolous.  In re Estate of Wejanowski, 920 So.2d 190 (Fla. 2d DCA 2006).

In conclusion, the best interest of the estate in Florida probate involves making wise, transparent, and lawful decisions to preserve the estate's value, honor the decedent's wishes, and protect the rights of the beneficiaries and creditors. It's a weighty responsibility, but with the right knowledge, support, and due diligence, it's a duty that can be fulfilled to ensure a smooth and successful probate process.

If you have questions about Probate issues, don’t wait—make sure your legal rights are protected. Call 863.250.2990 today to schedule your Free Consultation with our Probate attorneys.